Second Acts
Subscribe
Cover photo

He Was The Second African-American To Integrate Baseball

Baseball great Larry Doby forever lived in the shadow of Jackie Robinson. It's time he gets the recognition he deserves.

Ron Claiborne

Apr 20
8
14

Pop quiz. (1) Who was the second person to climb to the summit of Mt. Everest? (2) Who was the second person to walk on the moon? (3) Who was the second African-American player to play in the major leagues?

The answers: (1) Tenzing Norgay Sherpa followed Edmund Hillary to the peak of the world's tallest mountain in 1953. (2) Astronaut "Buzz" Aldrin stepped onto the lunar surface 19 minutes after Neil Armstrong in 1969. (3) Larry Doby played his first game for the Cleveland Indians eleven weeks after Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier in 1947.

In each instance, the first person who made those achievements was rewarded with fame and glory, their names etched in the annals of history. For their successors, the exact same achievements brought relative obscurity.

Last week (on April 15), Major League Baseball celebrated the 75th anniversary of Jackie Robinson's first game playing for the Brooklyn Dodgers. April 15th is now celebrated each year as Robinson Day. Every player playing in a game that day wears a uniform bearing his number 42, which is otherwise retired from the sport. It is an occasion to pause, reflect and remember the significance of what Robinson did, what he endured and what he overcame. Jackie Robinson is remembered today as far more than a great athlete. He is a civil rights icon, an American hero.

Far less well known is the saga of Doby, who went through the same tribulations as Robinson and arguably had an even harder path to acceptance. What he did, who he was and what he overcame is also worth remembering, admiring and honoring.

Photo credit: Getty Images

Jackie Robinson knew he would play in the major leagues and he knew it would be rough. He had signed a contract with the Dodgers in 1945 and spent the 1946 season with their minor league in Montreal, where he played before adoring home crowds. But he had experienced a taste of the racial hostility that awaited him playing at the Dodgers spring training in Florida in 1946.

In 1947, Doby was a star with the Newark Eagles of the Negro League. He had led his team to the NL World Championship the year before and was having a stellar season. Doby didn't know that Bill Veeck, the owner of the Cleveland Indians, was searching for a Black player that he could sign. He had wanted to integrate baseball back in 1942, but the baseball commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis shut him down. But now, five years later, Brooklyn had Robinson.

Just as the Dodgers' general manager, Branch Rickey, had sought and found in Robinson someone with the courage, maturity and even temperament to handle the pressure and inevitable abuse, Veeck was seeking a Black player with the same strengths. He was also looking for someone who could play at the major league level now without needing to spend time in the minors.

Veeck soon focused on Doby, then just 23 (Robinson was 30), who was an outstanding outfielder who hit for average, had home run power and could field. The Indians scouted for weeks -- unbeknownst to Doby -- and were convinced he was their man.

Veeck contacted the owners of the Newark Eagles and purchased Doby's contract for $10,000 with the promise of another $5,000 if he lasted a month. Doby had learned of the Indians' interest in him only a few weeks earlier, but he was skeptical it was real. Now, the deal was done.

Doby caught a train to Chicago where the Indians were playing the White Sox in early July. The Indians manager, Lou Boudreau, took him to the locker room at Comiskey Park to meet his new teammates. It did not go well. The players stood in a line to be introduced to Doby. Recollections of exactly what happened vary. In Pride and Prejudice: The Biography of Larry Doby by Joseph Thomas Moore, Doby recalled getting cold-fish handshakes from most of the players. Four refused to shake his hand, he said.

The next day, July 5th, Doby was inserted in the lineup as a pinch hitter in the seventh inning. With that appearance, he became the first Black player in the American League. He struck out. He then walked back to the dugout and sat down at the end of the bench -- alone.

"After the game, Doby quickly showered and dressed without incident," wrote Moore. "His escort took him not to the Del Prado Hotel downtown, where the Indians players stayed, but to the black DuSable Hotel in Chicago's predominantly black South Side. The segregated arrangements established a pattern, on Doby's first day, that he would be compelled to follow in spring training and during the regular season, in many cities, throughout his playing career."

The next game, Boudreau penciled Doby in the starting lineup at first base. Doby had never played first base and didn't have a first baseman's mitt. When he tried to borrow the mitt of his teammate, Eddie Robinson, Robinson refused to give it to him. Eventually, he relinquished it, but to a club official as an intermediary.

Throughout that season, Doby faced a barrage of racial abuse and vile epithets from fans and opposing players similar to what Robinson was going through over in the National League.

He would tell Jet magazine in 1978, "Jackie got all the publicity for putting up with it. But it was the same thing I had to deal with. He was first, but the crap I took was just as bad. Nobody said, 'We're gonna be nice to the second Black.'"

With a few exceptions, his teammates simply ignored him both on and off the field.

"If we were staying in the same hotel as the team, I wasn't invited to go out by the other players," Doby told Moore. "They might go to a place where I wouldn't be served, so they didn't do it ... I would go upstairs to my room alone."

In the book, Veeck is quoted saying, "Not only being the first in the American League but even more difficult was the fact that he himself had never really been exposed to the virulence that racism took once he donned an Indians uniform."

Larry Doby (left) with Jackie Robinson Photo credit: Getty Images

Doby and Robinson bonded over their shared struggle. They would speak by phone, offering each other support and encouragement.

"Jackie and I agreed we shouldn't challenge anybody or cause trouble -- or we'd both be out of the big leagues just like that," he said, according to a Sarasota Herald Tribune article in 1974. "We figured that if we spoke out, we would ruin things for other black players."

Doby's stats for the 1947 season were disappointing. He played in just 29 games, hitting .156. He struck out 11 times in 32 plate appearances. Robinson, meanwhile, had a terrific season and was named National League Rookie of the Year.

According to the book The Integration of Major League Baseball: A Team by Team History (by Rick Swaine), Rogers Hornsby, one of the greatest hitters in the history of the game and, according to Joe Posnanski in his wonderful book The Baseball 100, "a known racist," wrote, "Bill Veeck did the Negro race no favor when he signed Larry Doby to a Cleveland contract. If Veeck wanted to demonstrate the Negro has no place in major league baseball, he could have used no subtler means to establish the point."

Things would change dramatically for Doby in 1948. Playing regularly, he tore up the league, as the Indians won the pennant, For the season, Doby hit .301 with 14 home runs and knocked in 66 runs.

That season, three more Black players broke into baseball, including the legendary and supposedly 42-year-old Satchel Paige who joined the Indians.

In the 1948 World Series, the Indians would play the Boston Braves.

In Game 4, Doby hit the game winning home run. In the locker room afterward, Cleveland's pitcher, Steve Gromek, joyfully embraced a smiling Doby. A photographer captured the moment and the picture was widely published. Gromek would later get what he called "static" from friends for it. A long-time acquaintance shunned him. Looking back years later, Doby would say it was the highlight of his career.

Steve Gromek and Doby Photo credit: Getty Images

"The picture was more rewarding and happy for me than actually hitting that home run," Doby said. "It was such a scuffle for me, after being involved in all that segregation, going through all I had to go through until that picture. The picture finally showed a moment of a man showing his feelings for me. But the picture is not just about me. It shows what feelings should be, regardless of differences among people and it shows what feelings should be in all of life, not just in sports. I think enlightenment can come from such a picture."

The Indians won the next game and the World Series. Doby hit .318.

Doby would go on to play 13 years in the majors. He was a seven-time all-star. His career batting average was .283 and he clubbed 253 home runs. He once went 164 games without making an error, then a record.

He retired after the 1959 season. In 1978, Doby was named manager of the Chicago White Sox. Once again he was second -- the second African-American to manage a major league team.*

Jackie Robinson was elected to baseball's Hall of Fame in 1962, his first year of eligibility. Doby would not be chosen until 1998 and then by the Hall of Fame's Veterans Committee, which had the authority to select neglected players who are past their eligibility.

"If someone had told me fifty-one or fifty-two years ago that I would be standing here being honored by the Hall of Fame, I wouldn't believe it," he said in his induction speech. "But thank God I've lived long enough, and I certainly appreciate it."

Four years later, he died of cancer at the age of 79.

Doby, Satchel Paige and Robinson

.

Last year, Luke Epplin, author of Our Team: The Epic Story of Four Men and the World Series That Changed Baseball, about Doby, Paige, Veeck and pitcher Bob Feller of the 1948 Indians championship team, wrote an op/ed piece in the Washington Post calling on baseball to celebrate July 5th as Larry Doby Day just as it celebrates Robinson Day each April.

"Focusing so singularly on one player has had the unintended effect of obscuring those who followed in Robinson's footsteps, many of whose narratives differed significantly from his own," wrote Epplin. "Establishing a similar league-wide celebration to commemorate Doby's breakthrough would go a long way toward conveying a richer public understanding about the desegregation of Major League Baseball."

It's time for baseball to step up to the plate and recognize Larry Doby -- baseball great. Civil rights pioneer. American hero.

*Frank Robinson was the first. He became manager of the Indians in 1975

Cover photo credit: Getty Images

Subscribe for free to Second Acts
By subscribing, you agree to share your email address with Ron Claiborne to receive their original content, including promotions. Unsubscribe at any time. Meta will also use your information subject to the Bulletin Terms and Policies
Subscription provided by Meta. Help Center
Like · 8
Comment · 14
Share

More from Second Acts
See all

Living In Chains: Patients with Mental Illness in West African Prayer Camps

In nations with little psychiatric care, these religious retreats, despite horrific conditions, are popular.
May 12
10

Into the Heart of Darkness: Searching for the Stars In The Night Sky

Increasing light pollution is erasing our view of nature's celestial tapestry
May 4
3
4

He was No. 4 in the FBI. Now he drives a school bus

After the Marine Corps, FBI and chief security officer at Verizon, Michael Mason's "second act"
Apr 28
14
22
Comments
Log in with Facebook to comment

14 Comments

  • Author
    Ron Claiborne
    Thanks. Larry Doby's story -- courageous, noble, inspiring -- practically writes itself. You can almost FEEL what it must have been like and yet it's unimaginable. Think just about the fact he was 23 years old -- almost a kid -- had was thrown into tha…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Alan Daggett
    Ron Claiborne, I believe Mr. Doby what he was in the majors. Even though he played integrated baseball in NJ, I am sure he had faced racism. In the North, laws did not support racial inequality, but personal prejudices were just as bad up there as th…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Thomas Finley
    RC, you missed your calling. you could’ve been a journalist. Kidding of course, another excellent insight piece, than you.
    • 3w
  • Morna Friedberg
    Mr. Claiborne, what a great story you've written. I had the honor of meeting Mr. Doby when the company I was working for was hosting him and others. He was a true gentleman that evening. Anytime I hear someone mention Jackie Robinson, I instantly think…
    See more
    • 3w
  • Glenn Gage
    In 1967, Verona, NJ....we won the North Jersey PAL 12 yr league. Larry Doby was our invited guest! He gave a great speech and then presented us with our trophies. It was such a thrill! I was a small ss/2b and as I was announced and came up on stage, …
    See more
    • 3w
  • Jiminy StAck
    Great story. It had to be hard for many of them always being the minority and not getting equal rooms or returaunts. They played hard and well. I hope it is much better today.
    • 3w
    • Author
      Ron Claiborne
      And to think, Mr. Doby was 23 when he broke in. That's very young. He grew up in Paterson, NJ, played on integrated teams as a standout high school athlete and had no idea what he was in for in the major leagues.
      • 3w
  • Patricia Zywicki Difilippo
    My family had the honor to know Larry Doby in his later years. What a true gentleman and a class act.
    • 3w
  • Darryl Hodges-Haslerig
    Then who was Moses Fleetwood Walker and his brother where do they fit in as far as integration is concern
    • 3w
  • Stephen Wicks
    Once again Ron... I was hanging onto every word. Great article. Loved every moment. Thanks for sharing this history.
    • 3w
    • Author
      Ron Claiborne
      I meant to send this reply to you, Mr. Wicks" Thanks. Larry Doby's story -- courageous, noble, inspiring -- practically writes itself. You can almost FEEL what it must have been like and yet it's unimaginable. Think just about the fact he was 23 years …
      See more
      • 3w
  • Stanley A. Ross
    The Great Monte Irvin played baseball at Orange High School.
    • 3w
View 2 more comments
Share quoteSelect how you’d like to share below
Share on Facebook
Share to Twitter
Send in Whatsapp
Share on Linkedin
Privacy  ·  Terms  ·  Cookies  ·  © Meta 2022
Discover fresh voices. Tune into new conversations. Browse all publications